• Home
  • Diocese
  • Bishop Burns
  • Synod
  • Columnists
  • Revista Catolica
  • Vatican
  • Subscribe
The Texas Catholic
The Texas Catholic

Dallas, Texas

Today is Monday, March 27, 2023
  • Home
  • Diocese
  • Bishop Burns
  • Synod
  • Columnists
  • Revista Catolica
  • Vatican
  • Subscribe
  • Follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Linkedin
    • Instagram
Home
Columnists

Father Bayer: The evolution of worship

Wednesday, February 1, 2023

By Father John Bayer
Special to The Texas Catholic

I read a wonderful book recently that I think lots of people should read, especially science-minded people: Vestige of Eden, Image of Eternity by Daniel Toma. Dr. Toma is a geneticist at Minnesota State University, as well as a wide reader of Catholic theology from both the eastern and western traditions.

This book is enjoyable for being so synthetic, and for its readability despite being so clearly rooted in many great works of science, philosophy and theology. Toma says he writes for “the modern person of all stripes who is not acquainted with premodern thought, as well as the educated nonspecialist who is interested in a broad range of topics” (xi). In a culture like our own, which is so fraught with intellectual fragmentation and arcane specialists unable to articulate a vision for reality as a whole, this is an important book.

Toma advances a beautiful thesis: it is possible to integrate every genuinely scientific observation into a worldview that is eminently reasonable and highly suggestive of the Catholic vision of God and all reality. In this way, he shows how ideologies like “materialism” (or the denial of spiritual realities) and “scientism” (or the claim that the natural sciences are the only source of truth and that reality is totally mechanical and purposeless) are the result of a dubious choice rather than anything genuinely scientific.

Here I’d like to try to relate just one aspect of his thesis.

Toma outlines the basic story we have from contemporary science about the fascinating 13.7-billion-year journey of matter from subatomic particles to human beings. He expertly summarizes a lot of astronomy, physics, chemistry and biology. Then he shows how this story can easily be integrated into a broader story of ascent, which he calls “the hierarchy of being” – thus taking a phrase from the philosophical tradition, which recognizes that the story of cosmic evolution is not merely the rearrangement of matter into more quantitatively and structurally “complex” items. The story is not just about how an element formed later, like iron, has numerically more protons than an element formed earlier, like hydrogen, or that living things like bacteria have more “complexly” arranged parts than atoms. This story is true, but it does not express all that exists to be observed. There is also an increase in being, which can be expressed along a spectrum of interiority. An atom, for example, has a certain interiority at least insofar as it is in some way possible to identify its unity and thereby distinguish between its ‘inside’ and ‘outside’ or identify what belongs to it as opposed to its environment. However, an atom, just like every non-living thing, does not move itself: it is a unit, but it is a unit that is always knocked about by something outside itself. It is, therefore, less interior than what not only has an interior but is also able to move itself from within that interior. This is one way to express what “is more” in living over non-living things: the living thing is what has such deep interiority that it can move itself.

Living things too can be stratified according to their relative interiority. A plant has more interiority than an atom, but it has less than an animal. For a plant has enough interiority to grow and reproduce, and so its existence suggests the great cosmic story involves a rise in perfection (growth) and generosity (serving new life); but a plant does not have enough interiority to know. Its interior motion finishes entirely outside itself – in its fruit. This point might be more subtle, but Toma explains that higher order plants can indeed move in response to stimuli (like heliotropic plants following the sun), but they cannot, properly speaking, sense or know themselves or other objects. An animal, on the other hand, clearly has enough interiority to sense itself and others. A gazelle cannot know what a lion essentially is, but it can nonetheless recognize the lion as a thing different from itself, and as a thing to be feared. There is a further increase in interiority in that one very special animal – the human being – that not only senses a thing but also knows what the thing essentially is. Unlike the gazelle, the human can understand what the lion is (as opposed to sensing it as a vague “thing” with an associated emotional response).

What’s the take-away? Lots could be said, but the main point, if I understand Toma, is this: the universe is not dumbly there. Something marvelous is happening. The universe is moving. It is leading to a creature whose powers enable it to unite all creation in interior knowledge in order to offer it in loving friendship to the Creator. The structure of the universe leads to worship. We can arbitrarily reject this fact and assert against all evidence that we are an irrational coincidence. Or we can accept what is plain to see and ask why it is the case and what it is that we must now do – and what else God has done – in order to fulfill our magnificent role in God’s great design.

Father John Bayer, O. Cist., is a monk at the Cistercian Abbey of Our Lady of Dallas in Irving.

  • Tags
  • Columnists
  • Faith
  • Father John Bayer
  • Word to Enkindle
Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Pinterest
Next article Catholic bishop, youth and religious in South Sudan embark on long, grueling trek to meet pope
Previous article Kara and Peter Gehan announced as chairs for 2023 Bishop's Invitational Golf Tournament

Related Posts

Father Esposito: Happiness as the blessed life Columnists
Friday, March 10, 2023

Father Esposito: Happiness as the blessed life

Father Dankasa: Two voices in one Columnists
Thursday, March 9, 2023

Father Dankasa: Two voices in one

Prayerfully using Lenten seeds for Easter growth Columnists
Friday, March 3, 2023

Prayerfully using Lenten seeds for Easter growth

Texas Catholic Classics

A look at the five Dallas law enforcement officers who gave their lives while protecting citizens during a mass shooting in downtown Dallas in July 2016.

 

How a child with special needs inspired a high school volleyball team, community and a family who heeded God’s call to protect life.

 

After a young runner collapsed at a Dallas marathon, grace and providence unfolded for those involved in the valiant effort to help her.

   

In the summer of 2016, 50 students and 25 chaperones from Dallas Catholic high schools traveled to Nicaragua for a 10-day mission trip.

 

Early on a November morning, Kenndrick Mendieta bounded from the gym at Cristo Rey Dallas College Prep toward the campus’ athletic fields as clouds lifted on a fresh new day.

 

Subscribe

Get the award-winning Texas Catholic delivered to your door. Use the menu below to subscribe now.


Subscription length




 

Photo Gallery

Click here to find your favorite Texas Catholic photographs.

The Texas Catholic Newspaper

Catholic Diocese of Dallas
Michael Gresham, Editor

3725 Blackburn Street
Dallas, Texas 75219
(214) 379-2800

Our Affiliated Sites

Texas Catholic Youth

Revista Católica

Legal and Other

Contact us

Terms of service

Privacy policy

Site map

Site powered by TexasCatholicMedia

© 2013-2019 The Texas Catholic Publishing Company. All rights reserved.